What Anne of Green Gables, OCD, and Anxiety Taught Me About Living

Anaïs Nin once said, “Anxiety is love’s greatest killer. It makes others feel as you might when a drowning man holds on to you.”

I used to take this quote to heart in the way I lived my life. Throughout my childhood my seemingly incessant fears put others on edge. I didn’t take elevators. They could plummet underneath the earth and kill us all. Instead, I’d walk up the stairs and meet my parents at the floor they were on.

Anne of Green Gables, anxiety, and feeling like a misfit

When I’d drink water out of the tap I’d imagine cockroaches and tiny rats pouring out of the faucet and start choking on the water. Eventually, I had the same fear when drinking out of a cup.

I had a prayer, about five minutes long, that I compulsively repeated to myself dozens of times throughout the day. It went something like,

“Dear God, help me not to die in a car accident. Help my parents not to die in a car accident. Help me not to get pregnant. Help me not to bite my own tongue off in my sleep. Help me not to be kidnapped. Help me not to be in a nightmare but thinking I’m awake. Help the tribulation not to start…” and on and on.

This went on for years, from the ages of 8 to 11 or so. As you can imagine, it made it hard to make friends. When I thought of the prayer, I had to whisper it to myself, or I believed whole-heartedly that one of those disasters would befall me. No matter how embarrassing it was or how awkward I felt or how much shyness I was already dealing with, the prayer, I believed, would keep me safe. I’d be getting ten minutes into, what I hoped, was a “normal” interaction with another child when suddenly the feeling I had to pray would come on and I’d know that would be the kiss of death to my budding friendship.

The Worlds I Escaped To

During this time, I obsessively read books like Anne of Green Gables or A Little Princess. I felt kinship with characters who were outcasts but who dreamed of a better world. Nowhere was I happier than laying on the floor in my room, listening to oldies on the radio (it was the ‘90s so no Apple Music), and dreaming up stories or reading about new characters.

I’d imagine my future life in great detail; I would be competent, strong, and loved; but I wouldn’t need love. I’d have security, safety, and independence. I’d outrun all my fears by becoming totally self-sufficient and proving to myself that I was totally okay on my own and didn’t need anyone else to approve of me. All those kids who thought I was weird, all the adults who found my fears troublesome, I’d prove to them all that I could get by on my own. I didn’t “need” them.

Fast forward to 2025.

The realization that my OCD might actually be hindering my life even as a “high-functioning” adult came to me as I was driving back from dropping my daughter off at college in Colorado last November. It was a 24 hour drive home and at 1 AM I needed to stop for some rest. After getting my room key at the Holiday Inn I realized I might not have locked my car (I had). I checked the car, came back into the hotel, then realized, maybe I hadn’t “really” locked the car. I checked again. I found myself repeatedly finding reasons to “check” that the car was actually locked and that I’d shut all the doors. I was so tired and wanted nothing more than to curl up in bed and sleep, but fear kept tugging at me. I’m convinced the receptionist at the hotel was getting suspicious.

I don’t have some of the typical habits I associated with OCD: I don’t wash my hands till my skin bleeds or obsessively clean my room, rooting out germs. In fact, my room is usually the messiest place in the house. I’m working there now and as I look around I see notebooks full of half-written stories, poems, or work strategies. I see at least four cups on my side of the room, along with a pile of dirty laundry, some random craft supplies my kids brought in here, and always the stacks of books piled up on nearly every surface.

My therapist years ago suggested I might have OCD, but I hadn’t thought much of it. Now it’s becoming clearer to me as I sift through my memories. Times I counted things just so my mom wouldn’t die (even though one was not at all linked to the other). Times I’d adjust the way I was driving/walking/dressing so some absolutely unrelated disaster wouldn’t befall me. Turns out all of this had been an ongoing pattern in my life but I’d refused to really stare it in the face.

As a child, my weirdness felt like a death sentence. I felt sick to my stomach and would usually vomit before going to social events. Sometimes at social events I would suddenly break down crying and have to run off, because I’d become suddenly, painfully aware of how inadequate and “other” I felt around my peers. I still feel this way sometimes. Unfortunately, the world isn’t filled with red heads who want to tell you scary stories in the woods and be your “bosom friend.”

Learning How to Be Acceptable

Around the age of 15 I realized that if I could “look the part” some of my weirdness would be overlooked. I obsessively dieted, if you can call not eating at all dieting. I obsessed over every inch of my body, every hair on my head, and wouldn’t leave the house unless everything was perfectly in place.

I also learned that being acceptable as a teenager in 2000 meant acting like you didn’t give a damn about anything. Even though I most certainly did.

I was going to be “cool,” “aloof,” “disinterested”, and “beautiful.” I would act like I needed no one, even though inwardly I desperately felt like I needed someone. Anyone. But I would act unflappable and impossible to offend, kind but distant. Totally independent and autonomous.

I was not going to be the person in the Anaïs Nin quote. I wasn’t going to let my anxiety and OCD become “love’s greatest killer.” Maybe if people felt like I needed nothing from them, like there was no way in which they had to “hold me while I drowned” then it would all be okay. Maybe they would actually make space for me or…I don’t know…invite me to a sleepover or a movie.

My thoughts went along the lines of:

If I make myself desirable enough, I won’t be rejected.

If I pretend I don’t need anyone, I can’t drown them.

When Coping Just Changed Costumes

There have been many iterations of that thinking throughout my life that have shown up in different ways. Prayer turned into starvation which turned into workaholism which turned into…I don’t know what now.

The truth is, I’ve reached a moment where all those coping habits have stopped working for me. I deconstructed from my religious beliefs four years ago and am now an agnostic; not sure about any of it. Now, instead of starving myself I have to force myself not to eat indefinitely. Now instead of workaholism that yields results, my workaholism is crashing under the weight of increasing challenges.

A few years ago I made six figures as a writer. I thought I’d had it made. I’d worked decades as a writer for other people’s businesses, and now I was finally doing what I loved: writing about what I was actually interested in (personality types). I was finally secure. My family would eat and sleep comfortably until they were old I thought.

Fast forward to 2026 and now I make about as much as a fast food employee and I’m trying to make my family like rice and beans because groceries are so damn expensive.

I thought work would keep me safe, but hard work can’t control the future past a certain point. There is no safety in being productive enough. There is no safety in never needing anyone. There is no possibility of never failing.

But here’s the thing, even with all that, I still have moments every day where I feel this raw, ridiculous exhilaration at the beauty and magic of life itself. Sure, maybe I have to count the spoons as I’m putting them away now and then because I don’t want the apocalypse to arrive. But how lucky am I that I have spoons?!

I took this picture after falling and tearing the skin on my knees. It hurt, but I was so happy just to be there.

Learning to Listen Without Obeying

What I’m slowly learning — and I mean slowly, with a lot of backsliding — is that safety was never something I could manufacture. I just got very good at pretending I could. OCD convinced me that if I stayed vigilant enough, disciplined enough, impressive enough, I could prevent the worst outcomes. That if I stayed one step ahead of fear, it would eventually leave me alone. But fear doesn’t work that way. It doesn’t retire because you’ve been responsible. It doesn’t get quieter because you’ve suffered enough. It just waits for the next opening.

For most of my life, I treated anxiety like a problem to be solved rather than a condition of my version of being human. And every time one strategy stopped working, I found another. I mistook adaptability for healing. I mistook endurance for growth.

The hard truth is that OCD doesn’t actually care what form your compulsions take. It will happily trade prayer for perfectionism, starvation for productivity, devotion for discipline. All it asks is that you keep believing one thing: that it’s your job to make sure nothing goes wrong.

But if there’s one thing we’ve learned since the pandemic, it’s that we can’t really control all of that. And that feels simultaneously horrible and freeing.

Right now I’m in the process of seeing my OCD, my anxiety, as a part of myself that has one of my perspectives. But I have multitudes of perspectives.

My anxiety says, “You won’t be able to pay your bills in two months! Your children will starve! You’ll wind up homeless”

I pause, let myself hear that fear, then I say (in my head) to my anxiety, “Thanks. I know you’re trying to protect me. I’m noticing that there’s a thought telling me that everything is going to fall apart.”

I definitely don’t tell that part of me:

  • “That won’t happen.”
  • “We’ll be okay.”
  • “Everything works out.”
  • “I’ve handled worse.”

I don’t see my anxiety as the enemy or something to debate with and “win.” I let it exist alongside me, but I also am trying to let other parts of me exist too. Turns out, reading a lot of Anne of Green Gables didn’t really hurt me growing up. Yes, she once said, “My life is a perfect graveyard of buried hopes.” And I’ve certainly felt that before. But she also said, “Dear old world, you are very lovely, and I am glad to be alive in you.”

Both of these realities can co-exist together. I can be devastated that I had to leave my old home because I could no longer afford it. I can have moments of feeling like a total failure because of my weight, my awkwardness, or my career struggles. But I can also hold another reality in hand: That my heart is still beating and the January air in Georgia still smells crisp and delicious and tinged with autumn.

As Anne Shirley said, “There’s such a lot of different Annes in me. I sometimes think that is why I’m such a troublesome person. If I was just the one Anne it would be ever so much more comfortable, but then it wouldn’t be half so interesting.”

I love that. And maybe I love being “troublesome.”

When I was younger I thought “weird” defined me. When I was in my ‘30s I thought my ability to work myself into perpetual exhaustion defined me. Made me worthy. Safe. Good enough.

I have an anxious part. I have a part that wants guarantees and backup plans and certainty before it takes a step. But I also have a part that still wants to tell stories, still believes meaning can exist even when outcomes are unclear. A part of me that can put down the fear for a while and sit by the creek, being in complete rapture at the beauty of life itself. A part of me that can comfort my own kids anxieties because I’ve had decades of practice dealing with my own.

None of those parts need to be eliminated for me to live a good life. A lucky life. A life where I’m loved, in spite of still being “weird.”

Last year I watched a Korean show, Weak Hero, where the protagonist (an INTJ) is fighting with every inch of his energy to protect the people he loves. People think he’s “weird,” “unusual,” and a loner. There are many times he wants to give up, times he wants to stay away from people and avoid relationships because they could cause pain. But in the end, even with the risk of failure, loss, grief, and abandonment, he still gives everything he has to the struggle of life.

Stories like this exist to remind us that the struggle and pain and anxiety (and, sometimes, the OCD-ness) of life don’t mean we should give up. They also exist to show us that even quirky, weird, or unusual people who don’t fit in are not “bad” or “lost.”

I keep coming back to another line from Anne of Green Gables:

“We pay a price for everything we get or take in this world; and although ambitions are well worth having, they are not to be cheaply won, but exact their dues of work and self denial, anxiety and discouragement.”

Anxiety shows up whether we invite it or not. The real price is living anyway. Choosing to keep moving toward what matters without guarantees. Letting hope, love, creativity, and connection exist alongside uncertainty instead of waiting for certainty to arrive first.

Maybe this is what growth looks like for me now: not kicking anxiety out (that’s impossible), but refusing to let it collect interest. Not feeling like I have to control a hundred things that I absolutely cannot control.

I don’t know how everything will turn out. I don’t know what I’ll have to give up or take on in the years ahead. I only know that I don’t want to keep paying with my aliveness.

If there’s a price to be paid — and there is — I want it to be the honest one. The one that comes from staying present, staying open, and staying in relationship with a world that is beautiful, precarious, and unfinished.

Dear old world, you are very lovely.
And for now, I am still glad to be alive in you.

Family Dysfunction and Personality Type

Posted on
Have you ever felt like the veritable “ugly duckling” in your family? It might feel like everyone else fits certain criteria, but no matter how hard you try fitting in…

Can Childhood Trauma Impact Your Personality Type?

Posted on
Did you know that nearly 60% of adults report experiencing at least one adverse childhood event? These experiences often shape how we see the world—and even how we perceive ourselves…

INTJ Grip Stress: What it is and How to Cope

Posted on
For most INTJs, life is one long chess match. We like things to make sense. We like strategy, logic, silence, and people who can form a coherent argument without using…

Dealing with Dread for Each Enneagram Type

Posted on
Dread is that pit-of-the-stomach troll that shows up uninvited, usually right before you do something normal like open your email or brush your teeth. It’s not dramatic like a horror-movie…

Similar Posts

13 Comments

  1. Susan! I’ve been reading your work for years now, and this piece was heart-breaking, absolutely beautiful, raw, refreshingly authentic, just…incredible. Keep sharing your story. We need you in this world! You are making it a better place by being exactly you. ENFJ here rooting for you the whole way.

  2. Thank you for sharing. You inspire me to share these things back. I hope they are positive drops in your bucket like your writing has always been for me.

    I’ve taken that agnostic journey, too. Let it take you where it leads. Seek and ye shall find!

    One thing that helped me was when someone pointed out all religions taken to their logical conclusion excuse evil, except Christianity. Take that as you will.

    Also, when I heard about someone being killed while on the toilet when an airplane crashed into their home, I thought life is definitely beyond my control.

    One last thing: when God speaks to us, it is not like our parts. You will know.

    I want to say thank you for your writings about mbti. I have both enjoyed and found them so useful!

    I wish you so much joy on your journey! Thank you again for sharing.

  3. Thank you for sharing your story. It was vulnerable, honest and in so many ways universal. So many people have the belief that they need to “fix” themselves because they’re broken. No one is broken; we just have many parts to us. (Have you done IFS therapy?! Because the way you talk about your parts aligns with the model!)

    Some parts were created to protect us from suffering (anxiety), some parts were created to protect us from feeling unlovable (perfectionist) and other parts that protect us from shame (withdrawer) etc. We don’t need to rid ourselves of these parts because they serve a purpose. We just need them to soften so we can ultimately make decisions with compassion, clarity, calmness, curiosity, confidence, courage, creativity and connectedness.

  4. Dear Susan,

    I’ve been reading your writing since 2017 (back when you mistakenly identified as an INFJ). I highly value seeing your articles pop up in my inbox. Your content makes me feel understood and seen and has helped clarify other peoples processes so insanely much. Seriously helpful. Also, you’re quite a comedian!
    I’m so impressed to read this soul baring piece and I’m so sorry you had to leave the house you loved. Plus everything else you’re dealing with.
    I know this doesn’t help you in a practical way but I want you to know the positive and meaningful impact you’ve had on me. With all my heart, thank you.
    -Julia

  5. Thank you for sharing your story. And thank you for all the work you do. You are amazing. Big hug from Australia ♥️

  6. What a courageous article. My own path to safety (in recent years at least) has been avoidance – of people, of situations…Because after all, people are horrible – rude, mean, snarky, spiteful, saying things that I don’t have a quick answer to and thus which make me look (and feel) stupid. They’re unpredictable, changing personalities when you’re not looking, or unreliable, making me waste time or resources with their lack of attention or consideration. And after they’ve done these things they gaslight (at least in my head) and tell me it’s my problem. Even the “nice” people are ones I don’t have anything in common with and I still end up feeling…”other”. Or at least my Ti-Si loop thinks these things. I have to get out there, exercise my Ne and prove myself wrong, over and over…to convince myself otherwise – for a little while at least. And if I believe, in Christian tradition, that everyone is made in God’s image, I have to believe that He is working on them, too.

    One helpful resource I’ve discovered recently is Internal Family Systems (IFS), which contains the idea that each person (like Anne Shirley?) is made of many parts, which are often at war with each other. There are Exiles, which carry our unwanted feelings (fear, anger, anxiety), and Protectors which keep our Exiles at bay so we don’t have to feel those feelings. Those Protectors can be Managers (like work, or rules in my case – “Never do X, always check Y”) which proactively scan the horizon for threats, or they can be Firefighters which act after-the-fact to numb the pain, using addictions, self-harm, rage and other things. Protectors feel that they have a job to do, but in the wrong role they just make things worse. To me this system presents a more structured approach (and I like structure) to dissecting my own conflicting motivations and responses so as to ultimately give those Managers a break (or a new, more productive assignment) and bring my Exiles in from the cold. The therapy was developed by an atheist but the book I’m currently reading on the topic is written from a Christian perspective, and I personally find it compatible with Christian theology. It is within the Church that we *should* feel safest, even if we don’t always.

  7. Thank you for sharing this. I found it relatable and encouraging, and appreciate you being willing to be open about personal stuff.

    1. This is so beautifully vulnerable Susan ❤️💌 thank you so much for sharing. Wishing you and your family more peace & beauty in 2026 ☃️💫

  8. Hi Susan I read all you shared here .It takes great courage to share all you shared .You are not alone .I got sober over 36 years ago .I got a lot of help for myself .It took a long time but I finally got my true self back .We are proof you can get “ok”Thank you for all you shared .We surely aren’t alone .

  9. Thank you so so much for writing this powerful post. I felt and understood everything that you wrote, and I am actually shocked by how talented you are as a writer. Honestly, I identified with nearly everything you described in this article, and I legitimately feel seen and understood by this. Thank you.

    So I keep going between believing I am an INFP and thinking I am an ENFP. Sometimes I cannot restrain my intense desire for connection and love, and that gives me more extroverted tendencies. Other times, however, I get put down by my own anxieties and fears and the belief that I am too ‘weird’, as you described, and I withdraw from those I love and recourse to reading obsessively and writing novels. However the desire for love and connection comes back to bite me, and so I go back and forth between desperation and shame. I have identified strongly with Anne Shirley, and in childhood as well as now I have reread her story repeatedly and wished she was real. After all, who wouldn’t want a perfect bosom friend like Anne, who understands you and loves you passionately and loyally? She continues to be my favorite fictional character of all time, and she will always hold a special place in my heart. <3

    Like what you described in your beautifully written account, I also used to suffer from OCD, particularly in the religious and scrupulous form. I will not get graphic here, but it has led me to take it to extremes and utilize dark and elaborate methods to avoid hell and being unlovable. Now as an atheist/agnostic (still in question), I still carry those fears with me, but they take different disguises as you have presented. And yet I still feel deeply wounded, and I find it difficult to find something that will heal the wounds I have received from both religion and the extreme and sensitive tendencies I have. But I have felt so incredibly seen by this post…. in almost every way imaginable. Thank you so so so so much, Susan! I'm sorry, this post has been kind of crazy, and I am so sorry you had to go through all that. It took a lot of courage, certainly, and also to write that. Thank you (again.)

    1. Thank you so much Julia! That was the whole point of the article; to make others feel seen while also organizing some of my own thoughts related to all this anxiety. I’m glad if it in any way helped you feel less alone and less misunderstood.

      What you describe about going back and forth between INFP and ENFP is actually very common. A strong desire for connection doesn’t automatically mean extroversion, especially for Fi–Ne types. Both INFPs and ENFPs can crave closeness deeply, idealize relationships, and then retreat when shame, anxiety, or self-doubt kicks in. The swing you describe between longing for connection and withdrawing into books, writing, and inner worlds is something I see often, especially when someone has been wounded around belonging or acceptance.

      Also glad to meet a fellow Anne Shirley fan! Why aren’t there more Anne Shirley’s in the world?! We could use her right now. She represents that longing to be fully known and loved without having to dilute your intensity or imagination. I don’t see that desire as childish or unrealistic; it’s very human, especially for intuitive feelers.

      I’m also really sorry you went through religious OCD and trauma. That kind of experience can leave very deep marks, even long after beliefs shift or change. I’ve definitely had many negative religious experiences and totally understand the fear of hell. When I went from Christianity to agnosticism I hoped that fear would depart, but it’s moved on to another thing…just death in itself will always seem terrifying. The fear doesn’t always disappear, it just changes costumes, like you said. Feeling wounded by both religion and your own sensitivity is something many people carry quietly, and it can take time and gentleness to work through. I’m glad the post helped put words to some of that.

      Your comment wasn’t “crazy” at all. It was thoughtful, honest, and brave. Thank you for trusting me with something so personal, and for your kindness in sharing it. I’m hoping for both of us that we can make peace with the uncertainty of life and our inability to control all the various factors. You’re definitely not alone!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *